Friday Map Discussion: 19 October 2007

 

Friday Map Discussion Archive 

home

 

All Attachments

 

Hi Folks,

 

        The focus of Friday map discussion for 19 Oct'07 was on the extended warm spell over the central and eastern US and how the associated large-scale flow pattern favors autumnal severe weather outbreaks. It proved difficult to avoid talking about possible climate change versus natural variability issues, given the magnitude, extent and persistence of the regional extended warmth. The discussion is supported by the following (attached) figures and web links appended below.

 

1. Mean/anomaly 500/200 hPa geopotential heights for 5-18 Oct'07.

2. Integrated precipitable water for 0000 UTC 18, 20 Oct'07.

3. Mean/anomaly OLR for 20 Sep - 19 Oct'07.

4. GFS ensemble forecasts verifying 0000 UTC 26 Oct'07.

5. ECMWF 5-7 day forecasts verifying 0000 UTC 25 Oct'07.

6. SPC severe weather reports for 17-18 Oct'07.

7. CPC mean/anomaly 30-day temperature time series for Albany, NY and Chicago, IL.

8. Normalized NH 30-day 200 hPa geopotential height and 850 hPa temperature anomalies (R. Maue).

9. DT pressure, shear (DT-850 hPa) and low-level vorticity images for 0000 UTC 13, 17 and 20 Oct'07.

10. 850 hPa streamfunction and nondivergent wind for 0000 UTC 20 Oct'07.

 

I. Salient points:

 

1. NH 500 hPa flow pattern was characterized by a wave number 4 pattern for the last two weeks that was dominated by ridges over the east-central Pacific, central and eastern NA/Canada, the UK and central Europe. An anomalously strong Pacific jet and deep trough near the west coast of North America also characterized this

pattern.

 

2. Beneath the eastern US ridge, 30-day temperature anomalies averaged from 4-5 C as typified by Albany, NY and Chicago, IL. The 30-day standardized 850 hPa temperature anomalies ranged from 0.5-1.0 (> 1.0) throughout much of the central and eastern US/Canada (ridge region in the Pacific), and were < -1.0 in the deep

tropics of the western and central Pacific. The 30-day standardized 200 hPa geopotential height anomalies ranged from 0.5-1.5 over eastern North America, the east-central Pacific and parts of northeast Asia.

 

3. Mean/anomaly 200 hPa height anomalies over the Indian Ocean and western Pacific show the existence of an anomalously strong subtropical anticyclone from ~80 E to 140 W with slightly below normal heights equatorward of the subtropical ridge axis in the deep tropics.

 

4. The pattern of western/central Pacific ridging in the subtropics and midlatitudes with a trough downstream near the east coast of North America suggests the likely presence of heating anomalies over the tropical western Pacific and Indian Ocean regions. Mean/anomaly OLR images for the western Pacific and Indian Ocean regions for the 30-day period ending 19 Oct'07 showing the existence of an axis of negative OLR anomalies from the equatorial Indian Ocean eastward to the Dateline supports this inference.

 

5. Collectively, item's 1-4 suggest that transient disturbances embedded in the anomalously strong Pacific jet should move ESE toward and through western North America before turning ENE/NE toward the Great Lakes and eastern Canada.

 

6. Storms moving along the transient disturbance pathway identified in item 5 would be readily able to tap tropical moisture from the Gulf of Mexico. The poleward flux of tropical moisture in deep southerly flow ahead of these eastward-moving transient disturbance as they cross the Rockies is favorable for widespread severe weather outbreaks further east as evidenced by the 600+ SPC severe weather reports received for 17-18 Oct'07.

 

7. The integrated precipitable water field for 18, 20 Oct'07 shows a well-defined plume of tropical moisture (PW values > 50 mm) that extends from the western Caribbean and the Gulf of Mexico poleward to the Great Lakes and northeastern US. This plume (aka freeway) of tropical moisture and associated surge of tropical air contributed significantly to the favorable larger-scale environment for severe weather earlier this week.

 

8. An excerpt on Atlantic PV tails from the Friday map discussion post from 12 Oct'07 follows:

 

"At 00Z/9, a PV tail that ended with a weak PV maximum on the DT near 27 N and 70 W is associated with a low-level vorticity maximum near 26 N and 66 W. The low-level system proved to be non-developing, perhaps because of the relatively strong westerly shear overhead (not shown). By 00Z/11, general ridging had occurred over the west-central North Atlantic ahead of a transient trough over eastern North America. The PV anomaly on the DT, now near 30 N and 62 W, had become elongated and separated from the remnant PV tail to the east now barely detectable on the DT. Likewise, the low-level vorticity maximum associated with the aforementioned PV anomaly had also become elongated NE-SW in response to the increasing SW flow aloft. Finally, by 00Z/13 the PV anomaly in question had been carried equatorward to near 24 N and 52 W where it showed signs of reorganizing beneath strengthening northerly flow east of the still intensifying mid-Atlantic

ridge. Of interest is the obvious decoupling of the lower-level and upper-level disturbances as the former system is now near 30 N and 50 W, well to the ENE/E of

its position 48 h earlier."

 

        Of interest is that the aforementioned decoupled PV anomaly near 24 N and 52 W continued to move WSW before turning /W/WNW/NW around the equatorward side of the eastern US upper-level ridge. At 0000 UTC 17 (20) Oct this cold-core PV anomaly can be found near 15 N and 78 W (22 N and 87 W). High-resolution water vapor winds show a decided cyclonic circulation near the northern part of the Yucatan peninsula at 1200 UTC 20 Oct'07.  The 850 hPa streamfunction and nondivergent wind

map for 0000 UTC 20 Oct'07 shows enhanced southeasterly flow across the northwestern Caribbean and Yucatan Channel on the east side of the aforementioned PV anomaly. This southeasterly airstream, coinciding with the tropical moisture feed discussed above, turns more southerly and southwesterly over the extreme eastern Gulf of Mexico and Florida.

 

9. The future path of the PV anomaly mentioned in item 8) is of interest because the deep tropical moisture feed associated with it carries the potential to bring very heavy rains into parts of the southeastern US, where in many places the rainfall is desperately needed, over the next couple of days.

 

10. There is also some interesting forecast uncertainty with the next in a series of transient disturbances forecast to reach the central US. The forecast uncertainty is related to the strength and location of the cutoff cyclone forecast to form over the lower Mississippi Valley by 60-84 h. Successive runs of the 0000 UTC ECMWF, all verifying 0000 UTC 25 Oct'07, have moved the the cutoff cyclone progressively further east from near the New Mexico/Arizona border in the day 7 forecast to over Mississippi in the 5-day forecast. The implications of this forecast uncertainty on the rainfall potential in the Southeast, and perhaps another severe weather outbreak, are huge. An additional precipitation wildcard is our aforementioned wandering PV anomaly that appears to be heading toward the central Gulf coast, given the poleward-directed tropical moisture plume currently in place to the east of this PV anomaly. Finally, the 6-day GFS ensemble 500 hPa height forecast verifying 0000 UTC 26 Oct'07 also shows some interesting forecast uncertainty. Although a cutoff cyclone is present in all 12 ensemble members, giving high confidence to the likelihood that a new cutoff cyclone will form, there is still uncertainty as to whether the cutoff cyclone will hang back over the lower/middle Mississippi Valley or move more eastward across the southeastern US.

 

II. Inferences, speculations and science issues:

 

1. Can the persistent ridging over the central and eastern US for the last couple of months be related be related to tropical heating anomalies over the Indian Ocean and western Pacific, downstream of which a strong has been anchored in the subtropics and middle latitudes over the central Pacific?

 

2. Can the reduction in the (apparent) number of early autumn cold pools over northwestern Canada be related to the significant loss of Arctic sea ice north of Alaska and Russia during the just-concluded summer season?

 

3. Can the formation of persistent ridges at relatively high middle latitudes help to ensure an anomalous poleward transport of deep tropical moisture on the western flanks of these ridges as has been observed the last few days?

 

4. What are the physical processes responsible for the formation of deep tropical moisture pathways well into middle latitudes?

 

5. Are deep tropical moisture pathways more sensitive to midlatitude dynamical process and/or tropical thermodynamic processes?

 

6. As the climate continues to warm how will the "second" severe weather season change in the autumn? Is it reasonable to argue that there should be an increase in future autumnal severe weather outbreaks over North America based on increased deep tropical moisture when a trough is present over the western US?

 

7. Is there any reason to expect that upper-level troughs will become more common in autumn in a future warmer climate with a corresponding increase in severe weather activity downstream over central and eastern North America in conjunction with more robust deep tropical moisture plumes?

 

8. Can a first order estimate of future convective mode and frequency be obtained by constructing CAPE/shear phase space diagrams from multi-centennial integrations of sophisticated climate models.

 

9. Will there be fewer positively tilted upper-level troughs in autumn, a requirement for a poleward flux of angular momentum, in response to a weaker meridional temperature gradient in a future climate and, if so, will the frequency of cutoff cyclones increase at somewhat higher latitudes?

 

10. Can climate models be used to make first-order estimates of how the mix of large-scale flow regimes will change in a future warmer world and, if so, can anything be said about changes in the future frequency and behavior of transient disturbances associated with individual large-scale flow regimes?

 

http://cimss.ssec.wisc.edu/tropic/real-time/tpw/mainTPW.html (CIMMS precipitable water; Atlantic Basin)

 

http://amsu.cira.colostate.edu/gpstpw/ (CIRA blended precipitable water)

 

http://www.atmos.albany.edu/facstaff/rmctc/DTmaps/animSelect.php (McTaggart-Cowan UA GFS animation builder)

 

http://www.coaps.fsu.edu/~maue/extreme/ (Ryan Maue's Extreme Weather Page)

 

http://www.spc.noaa.gov (Storm Prediction Center)

 

http://www.cpc.ncep.noaa.gov/products/global_monitoring/temperature/global_temp_accum.shtml

        (Global temperature Time Series from the CPC)

 

http://www.cdc.noaa.gov/map/ (ESRL/PSD map room)

 

http://www.atmos.albany.edu/student/greenstein/EC%20ewall%200z.htm (Matt Greenstein's ECMWF forecasts)

 

http://www.meteo.psu.edu/%7Egadomski/ewallmref.html (Penn State e-Wall GFS Ensemble Forecasts)

 

.........................

 

A sign of the Apocalypse: Weather Channel music is now for sale online.

 

                                                        Lance

 

 

Response from Paul Roundy:

 

Hi, Lance and All. . .

 

In looking for connections between convective events in the tropics and mid-latitude weather patterns, it is helpful to examine how the tropical anomalies evolved with time through the period of interest.  I'm presently constructing a website for tracking the recent evolution of modes of tropical convection in real time.  The site is more comprehensive than others because it includes the influence of climate processes such as ENSO, the Indian Ocean dipole, the Madden-Julian Oscillation (ENSO), and convectively coupled equatorial waves in the same place.  The statistical system extracts wave signals from the OLR data without constraining the patterns to fit specific patterns of cross-equatorial symmetry (which the waves seldom exhibit in individual cases since convection coupled to the waves responds to seasonally varying basic states).  My release of this website is a bit premature since I have not yet added documentation, but I think it might be of interest to the group in relation to the reference to the monthly mean OLR anomalies Lance included in his note.  The site is at

 

Http://www.atmos.albany.edu/facstaff/roundy/waves/

 

 

select the link "Recent Evolution of OLR Modes".

 

The first panel represents the linear sum of the OLR anomalies associated with the different OLR modes shown in the other panels.  Active convection is suggested in blue shades.  The panel titles give the leading modes plotted in the panels.

 

Winds are estimated by regression onto the OLR modes and are at 850 hPa. The long barb in the lower left of each figure is 10 m/s.

 

Now to my point:  The major OLR anomalies that contributed to the 30-day mean were largely contributed by ENSO (panel e), the MJO (panel c), equatorial Rossby waves (panel b), and the Indian Ocean dipole (also in panel e, with the ENSO signal).

 

Incidentally, looping the maps over the last month reveals the different modes that recently contributed to a nice westerly wind burst over the equatorial west Pacific.  Multiple modes contributed to the longevity and intensity of the burst.  A Kelvin wave developed in the Pacific Ocean in response to the burst.  This wave is presently redistributing the warm water in the Pacific toward the east.  If the weather over the next 1-2 months cooperates with this wave, we might see an early end to our little La Nina.

 

Paul